Song - And I Love HerArtist - Shake Anderson
Original Version Recorded February 25–27, 1964
Roger And Dave Version Recorded: August, 2009
Vocals - Shake Anderson
Ukulele - Roger Greenawalt
Everything Else - David Barratt
Produced by David Barratt at The Abattoir Of Good Taste, Brooklyn from an original recording by Shake Anderson.
For best results play And I Love Her on repeat on your audio player while reading this essay.
ABOUT THE SONG
And I Love Her is a Paul McCartney ballad from the soundtrack of The Beatles debut feature film, A Hard Day’s Night. It is the first of several masterpieces he wrote for his then girlfriend, Jane Asher. From 1963-1968, Paul and Jane were the “It’ couple of what became swinging London.
There is some dispute about John Lennon helping to write the middle eight. I don’t buy it, And I Love Her reeks of McCartney’s worldview; the protagonist is cunning and confident with women.
The companion John Lennon ballad from the same soundtrack, If I Fell, is tellingly, vulnerable and insecure. If I Fell begins, “If I fell in love with you, would you promise to be true, and help me understand? ‘Cause I’ve been in love before and I’ve found that love is more, than just holding hands.” That’s Lennon to a tee, complex and contradictory, eliciting a promise of monogamy from some poor girl while simultaneously threatening to leave her if she doesn’t go beyond hand holding. That is, if she doesn’t go all the way.
Conclusion: And I Love Her is all McCartney.
The melody is glorious. The first line is “I give her”. It’s low in Paul’s vocal range, but then he suddenly swoops up on the word “all”, effortlessly, like a choirboy. He then sings” my love”; the word love being the highest note of the verse melody, signifying its importance.
Second line, first verse. “And if you saw my love, you’d love her too.” Again the word love is the same highest note as the previous line. And the lyric displays McCartney’s characteristic cockiness with chicks, he flatters Jane while pointing out to all his male listeners out there in the movie and radio land that he’s got the hottest girl and they don’t.
Verse two. “She gives me everything, and tenderly. The kiss my lover brings, she brings to me.” “Everything” is clearly sex, coitus, copulation. Hot stuff for its day, no wonder he throws in the innocuous verb “kiss” to throw the parents off the scent. But rest assured, the kids knew what he meant. Eventually. By Woodstock.
The groove is Latin Lite. George plays a lovely hook on classical guitar, which has nylon strings instead of the steel strings of an acoustic guitar. It’s sends the message “Look, we’re being sophisticated and tasteful here”.
The overall vibe is very Mad Men/Hugh Hefner, closing in for the kill. She’s taken her sweater off but the bra is still not quite unfastened. It will take mood music to seal the deal.
There is one glaring arranging error that disrupts this otherwise flawless production.
And I Love Her begins in the sky blue bright key of E major. Harmonically, it is deceptive, the chords initially go back and forth between F sharp minor and C sharp minor, signifying sadness, before the sun comes out and resolves to the tonic, E major. E major hits precisely on the word “love” in the phrase “And I love her”, again reinforcing in a chordal way, the primary importance of the word, “love” Amazingly, McCartney emphasizes this word melodically and harmonically within the first 30 seconds of the song. Quick work.
All is well until the classical guitar solo. But not for the usual reasons. George Harrison’s early solos were fraught with peril, he reportedly suffered from performance anxiety in the studio, a tendency that bored the more musically accomplished Beatles waiting around for him to get take 27 right. No, something even more terrible, and utterly atrocious happens.
For the first, and last time on any Beatle recording, they do a jump modulation. It must have been George Martin’s idea, Lennon and McCartney’s self taught yet impeccable taste would have precluded such a vulgarity. But there it is, right at the top of the solo, every single instrument suddenly switches from the sky blue bright key of E, with all it’s friendly cheerful chiming open strings, to the turgid, dark plum, dour key of F.
This is heresy to Roger and Dave. I know all you civilians out there (non-musicians) are scratching your heads thinking “big deal.” But it is a very big deal. Keys are not simply interchangeable, they have definite moods. That’s why all the classical geezers were so particular about what key a given piece was written in; so particular that they would often put the name of the key in the title.
If you’re not sure what a sudden jump modulation sounds like, see any song by Brittany Spears or Christina Aquillera circa 1998-2003.
The jump modulation is a cheap hack trick used to increase the excitement of a song that probably sucked in the first place. We shun this device. It’s like suddenly putting a 20th century city-scape behind the woman in the Mona Lisa instead of the bucolic Italian landscape that is actually there.
It’s just wrong.
Jane and Paul were ultimately unable to work it out. As Paul’s ego grew uncontrollably, Jane understandably became more and more disgusted with him. And as great as McCartney is and was, the truth is, he was simply not good enough for Jane Asher.
But Roger And Dave are.
We don’t beg often, but…we’ve written a letter. A very special letter. If you know Jane Asher, live near her, work out at the same gym as her, are the nanny for her godchild, or just see her pass by on the street occasionally, do see that she gets this.
Dear Jane,
There comes a time when even two strong, determined men must consider, if not admit defeat.
It has been a long, long…long time since you brutally broke up with Roger and Dave that Tragic Tuesday, leaving us weeping in the rain outside of your tasteful Chelsea flat. We miss that flat. And all the magic we made there together.
As we stumbled home that evening in tears, it never occurred to us that this many years later, you would not have returned a single, solitary, one of our phone calls. Or emails, letters, text messages, faxes, notes nailed to your front door, and poems attached to the legs of carrier pigeons.
And no Jane, legal documents like restraining orders don’t count.
Several years ago this would have been inconceivable, that you, our one true girl, would have forsaken us. When we were young we would waltz and rumba in dimly lit tunnels as shining white stallions would carry wagons of our love to be washed off and then smelted down into fine pieces of exquisite jewelry, which we would place secretly upon the perfection of your alabaster body as you gently slept.
Until that fateful day that you told us to get out.
We believed a love like ours, could never die. We still believe.
Oh, the endless, sleepless nights in the Roger and Dave circular bed, worrying and wondering. The languid, lonely days, unable to rise, staring at ourselves in the large oval mirror on the ceiling. This cannot stand. We must rekindle the sacred flame that is our passion; to prove once and for all, that everything we’ve lived and dreamed for, shall not die in vain.
So, Jane Dearest, it comes to this. If you doubt that we no longer love you, remove that doubt. Our love is deep. Too deep to be destroyed by the mere passage of time. Remember, forever love, that the time is always now.
Come home Jane.
We Love You.
Roger and Dave
ABOUT THE ARTIST
Sam “Shake” Anderson, started recording and touring at age nine. A bassist/guitarist/singer/songwriter/producer. Shake has worked with artists as varied as Bruce Hornsby, Static Major, Steve Cropper, currently nominated for a grammy with Felix Cavalieri, Earth,Wind & Fire, Aretha Franklin, The Indigo Girls, The Spice Girls, Curtis Mayfield, Aliyah, Ray Charles and Stevie Wonder. He spent six years as musical director for soul music legends "The Impressions".
Shake has also worked with a great variety of Christian artists such as Crystal Lewis, Annointed, Bryan Duncan, Israel Houghton and New Breed and Avalon.
Anderson, learned the most about life when an illness stopped him in his tracks. He was told he would never perform again and had several months to live. Life as he had known it was over. While spending more than nine months in the hospital and being told he was dying he learned who he really was—not Shake as the world called him—but Sammy Louis as his doctor's referred to him.
This crisis in his life taught him what was really important. Shake overcame all the odds and rebuilt his life. These songs—chapters—are stories about making mistakes, learning lessons and rebirth. Shake says about Stories from Sammy Louis—“once you've been to the edge the middle don't matter.”